Is My Injury Permanent If It Keeps Coming Back?
The same injury has been coming back for a year or more, through rounds of rest and rehab, and you’ve started to wonder whether it will ever heal.
If you’re an endurance athlete over 40, a runner, triathlete, or cyclist whose injury has been coming back for a year or more, it is most likely not permanent. Whether it resolves, and what it will take, depends on the state the tissue is in. A tissue whose repair keeps getting interrupted needs protecting, so the repair can finish. A tissue that has stalled partway through repair needs provoking, correctly, to raise its tolerance. The challenge with this is that you can’t tell the two apart by how the tissue feels, and the approach that serves one disrupts the other.
Why It Starts to Sound Permanent
When you have a nagging injury that won’t heal, after a while you might start to believe that it must be permanent. Maybe you even read or heard somewhere that past a certain age, that’s just how it goes, and you’re going to have to learn to live with it.
When you have an injury and go back to training too soon, while the tissue is only partway through its rebuild, the new tissue might get disrupted and you might set the repair back. The state of being interrupted doesn’t mean the situation is permanent. Clinicians such as myself typically find that most of what makes these things persist is interruption, and interruption can be corrected.
Protecting a repair like this means creating the conditions it needs and then not disrupting the work while it happens. Why Won’t This Nagging Injury Go Away? explains that cycle. After enough cycles of interruption, the tissue can end up in a second state that needs the opposite approach.
The Frozen State
The Frozen State is the strangest of the five reasons an injury keeps coming back: the tissue that is neither healing nor healed. Repair is supposed to be a process with an end. But a tissue that gets pushed through the interrupt-and-restart cycle enough times can stop cycling altogether and settle into a state: partially rebuilt, easily irritated, never finished healing.
In tendons this state has a name in the research, the degenerative stage of the tendinopathy continuum, and the way it behaves is exactly what makes it confusing to live with. It doesn’t behave like an injury, because nothing is actively repairing. It doesn’t behave like healthy tissue, because the tissue’s architecture is disorganized and its tolerance is low. It just persists. It flares up when its narrow tolerance is exceeded and goes quiet when it isn’t, because the process that would resolve it is no longer running.
The Frozen State matters for a specific practical reason: waiting alone rarely helps it. A tissue in an active repair cycle improves with patience. A tissue in The Frozen State has largely stopped improving on its own. What changes it is the right stimulus, dosed to what the tissue can tolerate, and rest alone never provides that. The disorganized part of the tissue may never fully rebuild, and with that stimulus progressed over time, the healthy tissue around it might build enough tolerance that you can train on it again. That distinction, between a tissue that needs protecting and a tissue that needs provoking, correctly, is the one the answer to this question depends on, and it is not one you can make from how the tissue feels.
Why You Can’t Tell From How It Feels
In either state, you go through the same loop. When you back off, it settles, and when you go back to training, it flares up again. In a repair that keeps getting interrupted, the repair makes progress during the time off, and the training load disrupts the new tissue before the repair finishes. In The Frozen State, the time off only keeps the tissue’s narrow tolerance from being exceeded, and nothing rebuilds while you wait. The pain and its timing can be identical in both.
Backing off serves an interrupted repair and does nothing for a frozen state. Loading serves a frozen state and disrupts an interrupted repair. Backing off means pulling back on training, and you keep doing low-load rehab exercise aimed at that specific tissue.
A common answer to this question is progressive loading, with no distinction between the two states. In The Frozen State, the tissue needs a stimulus that starts where its low tolerance allows and progresses from there. In a repair that is still being interrupted, that kind of loading is one more interruption.
Where to Look in Your History
You can discover The Frozen State in a history of repeated attempts that never quite finish, followed by recurrence. It is not typically where things start. It usually develops after other reasons have already been operating, when an injury has been through enough cycles of being pushed too soon, or too hard, and abandoned before the repair finished. Not doing what was necessary consistently enough for a long enough time is very likely the reason the cycle started. Some athletes in this position know it, and the battle is with themselves.
The other four reasons are covered in The Five Reasons Behind the Injury That Keeps Coming Back.
The Two Expectations
The challenge comes down to expectation. Some people experiencing this expect too much. They expect that the healing should be faster, that the things they’ve been doing should be working by now, and maybe they suspect they’re using the wrong tool or the wrong technique. On the other hand, some people have dampened their expectations, and they’ve settled for this being as good as it gets, that this is just the nature of their body now.
If you expect too much, it’s easy to abandon the work before the repair finishes. If you’ve settled, you may never start the work that would let it resolve.
What Resolved Means
Some long-standing issues do have structural components that set real limits, and an honest assessment matters more than optimism. Resolved means the issue is no longer preventing you from doing what you want to do, in training and in the rest of your life, which is a different standard from pristine. You train, and it isn’t a factor.
In many cases, cases where the individual is physically capable of healing and the proper set of circumstances is discovered and the proper work is done, healing generally can and does take place. It’s probably going to take longer than you want it to, and it’s definitely going to take consistent effort, but under the right circumstances, it happens.
An injury keeps coming back for one or more of five reasons, and usually more than one is operating at once. If you want to see which of them show up in your own history, Discover Your Reasons is a four-minute questionnaire, and your results appear as soon as you finish.
If you suspect that what’s described here runs deeper than any single issue, that suspicion has a biological basis. The Bridge explains what changed, and why the change was so hard to notice while it was happening.
The book, The Injury That Keeps Coming Back, puts the whole of it in one place.